Alright, I’ll admit it – this show could be absolute crap, and I’d still love it.
After all, I’ve watched most of the live action version, and I’ll claim to like that despite the obvious fact that J-dramas tend toward the awful.
Honestly, the third incarnation of Jigoku Shoujo Mitsuganae can be boiled down to this – if you’ve always liked the franchises, you’ll like this. If you’ve never liked Jigoku Shoujo, this isn’t going to change your mind, and might even convince you that you were right to drop it all that time ago during the first season.
This is the first season that the theme song was not done by SNoW, something I’ll admit to having been leery of at first, but Nana Kitade’s Tsukihana proves to be surprisingly good.
Anyway, I’ve always loved JS, and probably always will (if we get a fourth season, I’d be thrilled!), so I’m a bad person to ask about the actual quality of this show. I’ll admit that there’s been a higher amount of dumb this season than in previous seasons, but that the good stuff has been top-shelf. Episode twelve’s live action-ish portion is also worth mentioning, as it broke with previous convention of this show, and it also expanded into a medium generally not utilized in anime (the last instance of cut-outs being used was in the Antique Bakery OP). And I think such statements more of less bring me back to my original caution – I’m a bad person to ask about this show, because I’ll sing its praises until pigs fly out of Mamiko Noto’s ass.
EDIT: Also, JSM gets an epic win for ‘TATANIC’ in episode twelve – trying to find a cap for it, its ultra lulz.